In April, when the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission’s members gave their approval to expanding summer practices for sports programs, many concerns were raised.
For now, the state Board of Education is listening. The board tabled the idea, sending it back to the SSAC for further study.
We’re glad to see the state board is at least listening to concerns, but it would have been better to reject the proposal outright. And we refer back to our editorial of April 13 for the reasons why:
— West Virginia’s students are far from national leaders in academic performance. This initiative sends a message that we value athletics, while doing nothing to raise the ante for classroom performance. (If memory serves us correctly, the turmoil over possible year-round schooling drew more hue and cry than summer athletic practices)
— Summer has long been set aside for quality family time, whether it’s been vacation, working side-by-side in family businesses or just sharing down time and meals. The three-week practice period in June already has undercut this; the WVSSAC’s latest proposal would cause irreparable damage.
— Saying this would help West Virginia’s young people obtain college athletic scholarships is an empty motivation. The number of West Virginians who have received full (or near to it) athletic scholarships comprises a minuscule fraction of the student population.
— It’s very likely this initiative would open up West Virginia’s young people to overuse injuries. Kids who already play a sport in each of the three seasons now will spend a good portion of many of their summer days practicing (this practice period would be voluntary in name only).
— The WVSSAC envisions a détente in which coaches for each sport amiably split up the summer practice period. Football, for instance, might take a two-week window, baseball another two weeks, basketball a third two weeks, wrestling a fourth two weeks, etc. That sounds good in theory, but it won’t last. Some coaches, boosters, parents and even athletes will fall prey to the “keeping up with the Joneses” mentality, worrying that competitors will get an edge by practicing all summer long in one sport. Two weeks will give way to three, then four, and soon the entire period will be devoted to football. Or baseball. Or basketball. Or wrestling (and the same will hold true for girls’ sports).
— This initiative also would kill summer sports opportunities for kids who simply play for fun. How would baseball leagues like Pony or Babe Ruth or American Legion survive, for example, if high school and junior high coaches are holding practices throughout the summer?
— Summer-long sports also would have a negative impact on summer camps, be they traditional outdoor getaway events or academic sessions.
We know there are some coaches and educators who believe the expanded practices would help student-athletes. And to a degree, they are correct.
But the potential gain doesn’t merit the risk of potential harm.
In a nutshell, we rebuke the WVSSAC’s arguments that expanded summer practice would help potential college recruits. Those student-athletes eyeing that path have ample opportunity to work on their own or with summer league programs to improve.
As for the argument that the expanded practices would keep some kids out of trouble. We agree.
But so wouldn’t expanding reading, math and science classes. Any talk of those programs starting in the near future?
The state school board was right to at least temporarily sideline expanded summer practices.
We hope members see fit soon to end the discussion permanently. Three weeks of summer drills is long enough.
Post a comment as Anonymous Commenter
Report
Watch this discussion.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.